Field Notes from Failure: When Loss Leads the Way, And The Taste of Failure

taste of failure

Photo by cottonbro studio

Another taste of failure. Brandon’s screen flickers with the email he’s read twenty times:

“We’ve decided to go with another consulting firm.”

Six months of work. Countless meetings. A proposal he’d refined until every word felt perfect. All ending in a single paragraph of polite rejection.

His first thought comes fast and familiar: “Of course they picked someone else. You never belonged at this level anyway.”

His inner critic doesn’t whisper. It broadcasts.

I watch him from across our shared office space, expecting the usual aftermath of a lost client – the closed door, the intense focus on other work, the practiced professionalism that masks the wound.

Instead, he does something I’ve never seen. He pulls out a leather-bound notebook and starts writing.

“Looks important,” I say.

“Most important notes I’ll take all year.” He glances up. “Want to know what my old chef used to tell me?”

This catches me off guard. I knew Brandon had worked in restaurants to pay for college, but he rarely talked about it.

“In culinary school, they teach you to taste your mistakes,” he continues. “When a dish fails, your first instinct is to throw it out, start fresh, pretend it never happened. But a good chef? They sit with that failed dish. They taste it carefully. They find the story in the salt, the lessons in the burnt edges.”

He turns his notebook so I can see the header: “Client Loss – Anderson Project – Initial Reactions”

Below it, two columns.

On the left: raw emotions.

On the right: objective observations.

Left: “Not good enough for this level”
Right: “Proposal possibly too complex – simplify next time”

Left: “They saw through me – knew I was faking it”
Right: “Need deeper research on client’s industry – gaps showed”

Left: “Should never have tried for an account this size”
Right: “Scale-up strategy needs revision – build stronger mid-size portfolio”

“The left column,” he explains, “that’s the bitter taste of failure. The ego’s first reaction. I used to run from those thoughts. Now? They’re ingredients telling me what needs work.”

He points to the right column. “And this? This is the recipe getting better.”

“Seems… organized,” I offer.

“Has to be. Otherwise, the ego drowns out the evidence.” He writes another line. “Every ‘I’m not enough’ is trying to show you exactly where you can grow. But first, you have to sit with the taste of failure.”

I think about my own recent failures – the proposals that didn’t land, the clients who didn’t renew. How quickly I’d moved on, calling it resilience when maybe it was just running.

“My chef had this saying,” Brandon continues. “‘A burned sauce tells a better story than a perfect one.’ Know why? Because perfection doesn’t teach. It’s in the scorched spots, the too-salty bites, the collapsed souffles – that’s where the real learning happens.”

He closes his notebook. “But you have to be willing to taste it first. Really taste it. Even when it’s bitter.”

I notice he doesn’t look defeated. Focused, yes. Thoughtful, certainly. But not beaten.

“The Anderson account,” I venture, “will you try for something that size again?”

“Bigger,” he says. “But differently. Better recipe now.”

Here’s what I learned watching Brandon that day:

True growth isn’t about bouncing back fast. It’s about sitting with the experience long enough to extract its lessons.

The ego’s first reactions – the “not enough,” the “who do you think you are,” the “you never belonged here” – they’re not verdicts. They’re signposts pointing to where growth is possible.

Want to turn setbacks into strength?
Start here:

  1. Catch the First Taste of failure
  • Write down your immediate emotional reactions
  • Don’t judge them – just document
  • Notice what stories your ego tells
  1. Find the Ingredients
  • What specifically went wrong?
  • Where were the gaps?
  • What assumptions proved false?
  1. Revise the Recipe
  • What needs to change?
  • Where can you grow?
  • What systems need updating?
  1. Plan the Next Meal
  • Set concrete action steps
  • Build on what you learned
  • Aim higher, but differently

Two months later, Brandon landed an account twice the size of Anderson. Not because he’s naturally resilient. Not because he “stayed positive.” But because he learned to taste his mistakes, to find the lessons in the bitter moments.

Your setbacks are serving you something. The question is: Are you willing to sit at the table long enough to understand what it’s trying to teach you?

Stop running from the taste of failure. Start developing your palate for progress.

Because the strongest growth doesn’t come from getting it right the first time.

It comes from learning to find the lessons in every bitter bite.